- Boxes
- definitions
- Ellipses
- theorems and lemmas
- Blue border
- the statement of this result is ready to be formalized; all prerequisites are done
- Orange border
- the statement of this result is not ready to be formalized; the blueprint needs more work
- Blue background
- the proof of this result is ready to be formalized; all prerequisites are done
- Green border
- the statement of this result is formalized
- Green background
- the proof of this result is formalized
- Dark green background
- the proof of this result and all its ancestors are formalized
- Dark green border
- this is in Mathlib
The symmetry also follows without the formula: if \(M\) is the matrix of the resonant pulse and \(M'\) the one with the rates exchanged, then \(M'=(\Pi M\Pi )^{\mathsf T}\) for the transposition \(\Pi \), so \((e^{M't})_{21}=(e^{Mt})_{21}\). No relation between \(G\) and the rates is needed: the critical and over-damped cases follow from the same comparison, because the maximum of \(F\) comes before the zero of \(\omega \). (For \(G=1\), \({\gamma _q}=5\), \({\gamma _m}=0\): \(t_*=\tfrac 43\ln 2\) and \(P_*=2^{-10/3}\approx 0.0992\).) Figure 1 shows \(1-P_*\) for both rates from \(10^{-3}G\) to \(G/2\). The Isabelle/HOL formalisation of the bound over all pulses covers the three regimes, on the reduced population equations. The over-damped case uses the eigen-coordinates of the resonant matrix and a logarithmic Lyapunov function, and the critical case its Jordan coordinates (no polar angle); the delicate case \(\delta \le -4G\) appears as the positivity of one coordinate.
Since the optimum is at \(\tan \theta _*=2G/{\gamma _m}\), the resonant pulse should be stopped when \(|a(t)|/|b(t)|={\gamma _m}/(2G)\), in all three regimes. With \({\gamma _m}=0\) the rule is complete transfer, \(a=0\). The rule needs only the ratio of the amplitudes, not \(t_*\).
Figure 2 tests the theorem against 1500 random pulses in a strongly dephased case. When the two relaxation rates are equal there is a proof in the style of Theorem 1, with no optimal control theory; it is in Appendix A and also gives the optimality of the resonant pulse at each fixed short duration. When there is no relaxation and \(\Phi {\lt}4G\) the supremum is explicit: \(P_\phi =\tfrac 12\bigl(1+e^{-\pi \Phi /(2\omega _p)}\bigr)\) with \(\omega _p=\sqrt{4G^2-\Phi ^2/4}\); for \(\Phi \ge 4G\) it is \(1/2\) and is not attained. For the same reason the infimum in Corollary 9 need not be attained (with \(G=1\), no relaxation and \(\phi _q=\phi _m=10\) the resonant pulse gives \(r(t){\gt}5/12\) for every \(t\) and \(r(t)\to 5/12\); Proposition 11 shows that no pulse does better). With positive relaxation rates the error tends to \(1/2\) as the duration grows, so the resonant family attains its own infimum at a finite duration; existence of an optimal control over all pulses (with unbounded detuning) is not claimed.
MarBprop:slow2used-byMarBprop:noiselossused-by Memory_Access_Floors.write_channel_infidelity, Memory_Access_Floors.worst_case_case_one, Memory_Access_Floors.worst_case_case_two Let \(c_*=\sqrt{P_*(2\eta _q,2\eta _m;G)}\) (assuming \(G{\gt}|\eta _q-\eta _m|/2\)) and let \(r_{\mathrm{opt}}\) be the infimum of \(r\) over all pulses and durations. Then
where \(c_{\mathrm{res}}(t)=G\, e^{-(\eta _q+\eta _m)t/2}\, |\sin \omega _ct|/\omega _c\), \(\omega _c^2=G^2-(\eta _q-\eta _m)^2/4\). The same pulses are optimal for \(F\) and for \(F_e\).
Robust_Cost_Branches.fixed_duration_envelope, Robust_Cost_Branches.envelope_ge_resonant Let \(\mu =\min ({\gamma _q},{\gamma _m})\) and \(\nu =\min (\eta _q,\eta _m)\). For every prescribed duration \(T\) the largest transferred population and the largest transferred coherence over all pulses are
Each is attained by a resonant pulse of the maximising duration \(s\) and a wait of \(T-s\) in the element with the smaller rate \(\gamma \) (for \(B_c\): the smaller rate \(\eta \)), before the pulse if that element is the qubit and after it if it is the mode.
Memory_Time_Bound.time_bound, Memory_Time_Bound.time_equality, Memory_Time_Bound.time_limit With \(B_p,B_c\) of Corollary 8,
If the supremum is attained at a duration \(T_0\) at which \(B_p(T_0)=p_{\mathrm{res}}(T_0)\) and \(B_c(T_0)=c_{\mathrm{res}}(T_0)\), then \(r_{\mathrm{opt}}=r_{\mathrm{res}}\): the resonant pulse is exactly optimal for the average fidelity. The same holds if the supremum is approached along durations \(T_n\) with \([B_p(T_n)-p_{\mathrm{res}}(T_n)]+2[B_c(T_n)-c_{\mathrm{res}}(T_n)]\to 0\).
Unequal_Sufficient_Region.psuf_kappa, Unequal_Sufficient_Region.psuf_a, Unequal_Sufficient_Region.psuf_initial, Unequal_Sufficient_Region.exp_step, Unequal_Sufficient_Region.sinh_ratio_mono, Unequal_Sufficient_Region.resonant_ratio, Unequal_Sufficient_Region.coth_step, Unequal_Sufficient_Region.initial_interval Take the class of Proposition 12 and units \(G=1\), but with \(1{\lt}\delta {\lt}\sqrt5\). Put \(s=\operatorname {artanh}(\Omega /\delta )/\Omega \) and \(L=\log (2/\Omega )/s\). If
then every pulse has \(p+2c{\lt}\tfrac 12\) at every duration, and \(r_{\mathrm{opt}}=5/12\), not attained. For instance \(P_{\rm suf}(2)=3.6911216538\ldots \): at \(|\phi _q-\phi _m|=4G\) the threshold lies in \([3G^2,3.6912\, G^2]\), where the envelope bound of Corollary 8 certifies only from \(4G^2\).
Memory_Floors_Pieces.chan_comp, Memory_Floors_Pieces.valid_chan_comp, Memory_Floors_Pieces.cycle_channel, Memory_Floors_Pieces.cycle_floor Markovian rates; write, wait a time \(t\) in the memory with no coupling, read back into the qubit, and assume that the transmon is reset to its ground state between the write and the read (what it still holds is lost, as in the channel \(\mathcal E_{p,c}\)). Then the write–wait–read channel is \(\mathcal E_{p,c}\) with \(p=p_wp_re^{-{\gamma _m}t}\) and \(c=c_wc_re^{-\eta _mt}\), the read obeys the same bounds as the write, and
Here \(P_\phi =\sup _{s\ge 0}p_{\mathrm{res}}(s)\) and \(c_*=\sup _{s\ge 0}c_{\mathrm{res}}(s)=\sqrt{P_*(2\eta _q,2\eta _m;G)}\), with the continuous and hyperbolic forms of Theorem 1 used at critical damping and overdamping. The known accumulated phase is corrected at the output.
Memory_Access_Dephasing.P1, Memory_Access_Dephasing.P3, Memory_Access_Extras.memory_dephasing_equal_rates_free Let \({\gamma _q}={\gamma _m}=\gamma \) and \(\Phi {\lt}4G\). Put \(\omega (\beta )=2G-\tfrac \Phi 2\sin 2\beta \), \(R(\beta )=-\int _0^\beta \Phi \sin ^2\! /\omega \) and \(\tau (\beta )=\int _0^\beta 1/\omega \). For every control and every \(T\),
and \(p_b(T)\le p_{\mathrm{res}}(T)\) for every \(T\le \tau (\pi /2)\).
Equal_Rate_Threshold.gap_lower_bound, Equal_Rate_Threshold.gap_at_midpoint, Equal_Rate_Threshold.gap_min_value, Equal_Rate_Threshold.wph1_deriv, Equal_Rate_Threshold.wph1_stationary, Equal_Rate_Threshold.wph1_negative Let \(\varepsilon =\max ({\gamma _q},{\gamma _m},\phi _q,\phi _m)/G\).
Without dephasing (\(\Phi =0\)), \(c_{\mathrm{res}}=\sqrt{p_{\mathrm{res}}}\), so \(r_{\mathrm{sep}}=r_{\mathrm{opt}}=r_{\mathrm{res}}\): the resonant pulse stopped at its first maximum is exactly optimal for \(r\) and for \(F_e\).
In general the population maximum does not move with the dephasing to first order, the coherence maximum comes earlier by \(\Phi /(2G^2)\), and
\[ r_{\mathrm{res}}-r_{\mathrm{sep}}=\frac{\Phi ^2}{48\, G^2}+O(\varepsilon ^3) . \]
Memory_Cycle_No_Reset.change_of_variables_ineq, Memory_Cycle_No_Reset.F_derivative_pi_half, Memory_Cycle_No_Reset.every_minimiser_below_pi_half, Cycle_Utility_Threshold.rho_concave, Cycle_Utility_Threshold.rho_zero_lt, Cycle_Utility_Threshold.rho_ge_rho_one, Cycle_Utility_Threshold.F_t_difference, Cycle_Utility_Threshold.F_t_ge, Cycle_Utility_Threshold.rho_slope_gt Fix a direction of non-negative Markovian rates and scale it by \(\varepsilon \). Fix, independently of \(\varepsilon \), a write–wait–read control with no reset (\(|g|\le G\), any phase and detuning; a wait of time \(t\) with no coupling) whose zero-rate propagator returns the excitation to the qubit up to a known phase, corrected at the output. Put
Then \(r_{\rm cycle}=r_1+O(\varepsilon ^2)\) for each control, with
attained by a resonant write stopped at a minimiser \(\theta _*\), the wait, and the inverse resonant read (the same pulse with the coupling phase inverted, the phase of the wait compensated). If \({\gamma _m}+\phi _m{\gt}0\), then \(\theta _*{\lt}\pi /2\) for every \(t{\gt}0\): the optimal cycle never completes the swap, and \(r_1^*(t)\) lies strictly below \(F_t(\pi /2)\), the first-order part of the floor of Proposition 17. Accessing the memory pays at this order exactly for \(t{\gt}t_c\), where, with \(A(\theta )=\frac2G\int _0^\theta \rho (\cos ^2u)\, du\) and \(d(\theta )=\rho (1)-\rho (\cos ^2\theta )\),
in the first case \(d\le 0\) and not accessing (\(\theta =0\)) is optimal for every \(t\); in the second \(t_c\) is finite, not accessing and a nonzero parking angle tie at \(t_c\), and since \(F_t'(0)=\frac2G\rho (1){\gt}0\) the onset is a jump to a finite angle. If \(0{\lt}{\gamma _m}+\phi _m{\lt}{\gamma _q}+\phi _q\), then every minimiser tends to \(\pi /2\) as \(t\to \infty \), and
MarBrem:corrused-byMarBrem:relaxanswered-byMarBrem:unifiedanswered-by MarBprop:slow2answered-byMarBprop:noiselossanswered-by Quasistatic_Average.qs_average, Quasistatic_Average.qs_average_uncorrelated, Memory_Access_Quasistatic.qsA_ge, Memory_Access_Quasistatic.qsA_pop_coh, Memory_Access_Quasistatic.qs_pointwise (a) With quasi-static offsets as the only noise (no relaxation and no Markovian pure dephasing), the resonant pulse of duration \(\pi /(2G)\) has
for offsets with \(\mathbb E[\xi _q\xi _m]=0\) (in particular centred uncorrelated offsets), whatever their distribution with finite second moments. (b) With relaxation rates \({\gamma _q},{\gamma _m}\) and independent centred Gaussian offsets, every pulse of every duration has
where \(B_p^{(0)},B_c^{(0)}\) are the envelopes of Corollary 8 with the relaxation rates alone (\(\phi _q=\phi _m=0\)); set \(v_\perp =0\) when \(\sigma _q=\sigma _m=0\), and the bound then reduces to the relaxation-only envelope bound.
Memory_Floors_Pieces.f_res_min, Memory_Floors_Pieces.f_env_large, Memory_Floors_Pieces.f_env_small Let \(\nu =\min (\eta _q,\eta _m)\) and \(\Phi =\phi _q+\phi _m\). Fix \(G{\gt}0\) and a nonnegative rate direction \((\hat\gamma _q,\hat\gamma _m,\hat\varphi _q,\hat\varphi _m)\), normalised to have maximum component one, and set \(({\gamma _q},{\gamma _m},\phi _q,\phi _m)=\varepsilon G(\hat\gamma _q,\hat\gamma _m,\hat\varphi _q,\hat\varphi _m)\). All statements below concern \(\varepsilon \downarrow 0\) along this fixed direction; the required upper bound on \(\varepsilon \) may depend on the direction.
If \(4\nu {\gt}\Phi \), then for all small enough \(\varepsilon \), \(r_{\mathrm{opt}}=r_{\mathrm{res}}\): the resonant pulse, stopped at its best duration, is exactly optimal for the average fidelity.
In general \(r_{\mathrm{res}}-r_{\rm time}=\max (0,\Phi -4\nu )^2/(48G^2)+O(\varepsilon ^3)\): the undecided width between the bound of Corollary 10 and the resonant pulse is of second order. Its quadratic term vanishes when \(4\nu \ge \Phi \); exact equality is asserted in part (a) under the strict condition \(4\nu {\gt}\Phi \).
Oscillator_Comparison.strong_comparison, Oscillator_Comparison.zz_lower, Oscillator_Comparison.coherence_integral_bound, Oscillator_Comparison.strong_conclusion, Oscillator_Comparison.strong_unequal_chain Memory_Access_Quasistatic.strong_z_ge, Memory_Access_Quasistatic.strong_z_antimono, Memory_Access_Quasistatic.strong_gap, Memory_Access_Quasistatic.strong_limit Without relaxation and with dephasing rates \(\phi _q,\phi _m\ge 4G\), \(r_{\mathrm{opt}}=r_{\mathrm{res}}=5/12\), and no pulse of finite duration attains it. For equal rates \(\phi _q=\phi _m=\varphi \) there is a unique \(\varphi _*\), certified in \(2.0941221534\, G{\lt}\varphi _*{\lt}2.0941221542\, G\) (equivalently \(\phi _q+\phi _m\approx 4.18824\, G\)): for \(\varphi {\gt}\varphi _*\) the same holds; at \(\varphi =\varphi _*\), \(r_{\mathrm{opt}}=5/12\) and the resonant pulse attains it at one finite duration; for \(\varphi {\lt}\varphi _*\) the resonant pulse itself reaches \(r{\lt}5/12\) at a finite duration.
Memory_Floors_Pieces.omega_le_kappa_iff, Memory_Floors_Pieces.vertex_ineq, Memory_Floors_Pieces.delta_sq_over_omega_lt_a, Memory_Floors_Pieces.final_bound, Storage_Function.reduce_yz, Storage_Function.reduce_uh, Storage_Function.cone_yz, Storage_Function.cone_uh, Storage_Function.log_step, Metzler_Cone.ratio_nonincreasing, Storage_Function.unequal_storage_bound, Unequal_Dephasing_Threshold.threshold_3G2, Unequal_Dephasing_Threshold.eventually_four_u_gt_w, Unequal_Dephasing_Threshold.p_plus_2c_iff, Unequal_Dephasing_Threshold.resonant_below_five_twelfths No relaxation; pulses of fixed phase and no detuning, \(0\le g(t)\le G\); \(\delta =|\phi _q-\phi _m|/2\ge \sqrt5\, G\) and \(\Omega =\sqrt{\delta ^2-G^2}\). Then \(r_{\mathrm{opt}}=5/12\), not attained, if and only if \(\phi _q\phi _m\ge 3G^2\). More precisely:
if \(\phi _q\phi _m\ge 3G^2\), every pulse has \(c(T)\le \frac{G}{2\Omega }\bigl(1-2p(T)\bigr)\) and \(p(T){\lt}\tfrac 12\) at every duration, hence \(p+2c{\lt}\tfrac 12\);
if \(\phi _q\phi _m{\lt}3G^2\), the resonant pulse has \(p+2c{\gt}\tfrac 12\) at all long enough durations.
The bound of Theorem 1 holds for the population under any dephasing, Markovian or not: for a state of the one-excitation block the populations obey the first line of (2) and positivity gives \(|\rho _{ab}|\le \sqrt{p_ap_b}\), which is all the proof used. So \(p_b\le P_*({\gamma _q},{\gamma _m};G)\) always, and \(P_\phi \le P_*\) is the sharper value when the dephasing is Markovian with known rates.
relaxation only (no dephasing); two states; |g| <= G; no relation between G and the rates Memory_Access_All_Pulses.memory_access_all_pulses, Memory_Access_Over.memory_access_over, Memory_Access_Over.memory_access_critical, Memory_Access_All_Pulses.bound_sharp, Memory_Access_Floors.resonant_pulse_max_bound, Memory_Access_Floors.resonant_pulse_max_attained, Memory_Access_Floors.max_population_symmetric, Memory_Access_Extras.folk_number_bound, Memory_Access_Regimes.over_pulse_global_max, Memory_Access_Regimes.over_pulse_max_attained, Memory_Access_Regimes.critical_pulse_max, Memory_Access_Regimes.log_derivative_identity, Memory_Access_Regimes.folk_bound_over Let \({\bar\gamma }=({\gamma _q}+{\gamma _m})/2\) and
For every control in (1) and every \(t\ge 0\),
with equality for the resonant pulse \(g\equiv G\), \(D\equiv 0\) stopped at \(t_*\) (this optimal stopping time and value of the resonant pulse, in all three regimes, are Eqs. (16)–(17) of [ 16 ] ). In the under-damped case \(P_*=\frac{4G^2}{4G^2+{\gamma _q}{\gamma _m}}\exp \bigl(-\frac{{\bar\gamma }}{\Omega }\arctan \frac{2\Omega }{{\bar\gamma }}\bigr)\); in the over-damped case \(P_*=\frac{4G^2}{4G^2+{\gamma _q}{\gamma _m}}\bigl(\frac{{\bar\gamma }-2\kappa }{{\bar\gamma }+2\kappa }\bigr)^{{\bar\gamma }/(2\kappa )}\), real because \({\bar\gamma }^2-4\kappa ^2=4G^2+{\gamma _q}{\gamma _m}{\gt}0\). In particular \(P_*\) is symmetric in the two rates, and
with \(\ln P_*=-\pi ({\gamma _q}+{\gamma _m})/(4G)+({\gamma _q}^2+{\gamma _m}^2)/(8G^2)+O(\gamma ^3/G^3)\): the familiar estimate of the loss of the standard pulse is a rigorous upper bound for the smallest loss. (If \({\gamma _q}={\gamma _m}=0\), read \(t_*=\pi /(2G)\) and \(P_*=1\).)
Fixed_Duration_Core.H_max, Fixed_Duration_Core.h0_negative, Fixed_Duration_Core.H_aligned_cases, Fixed_Duration_Core.case_i, Fixed_Duration_Core.case_ii, Fixed_Duration_Core.case_iii, Fixed_Duration_Core.case_iv, Fixed_Duration_Core.epsilon_limit, Fixed_Duration_Core.lyapunov_conclusion, Pop_Lyapunov_Step.dini_danskin, Pop_Lyapunov_Step.dini_monotone, Pop_Lyapunov_Step.v_antitone, Pop_Lyapunov_Step.pb_bound relaxation rates and pure dephasing rates non-negative and constant; Markovian dephasing; two states; |g| <= G Let \({\gamma _q},{\gamma _m},\phi _q,\phi _m\ge 0\). Along every solution of (2) with \(|g|\le G\), from any positive initial block, the function \(t\mapsto V_{T-t}(R(t))\) is non-increasing on \([0,T]\). Hence, for \(p_a(0)=1\) and every \(T\),
and in particular \(p_b(T)\le p_{\mathrm{res}}(T)\) for every \(T\) up to the first maximum of \(p_{\mathrm{res}}\). Since the right-hand side is at most \(P_\phi \) for every finite \(T\), this proves Theorem 4 without the existence of an optimal control.
MarBprop:costcomparesMarBthm:robustsame-setting Memory_Access_Floors.alignment_lemma Let \({\gamma _q},{\gamma _m},\phi _q,\phi _m\ge 0\) and \(G{\gt}0\). For every measurable control with \(|g|\le G\), every detuning and every duration, the solution of (2) with \(p_a(0)=1\) satisfies
where \(p_{\mathrm{res}}\) is the population transferred by the resonant pulse \(g\equiv G\), \(D\equiv 0\):
No relation between \(G\) and the rates is assumed.