Gate-time lower bound from the eigenphase gap #
A gate G is implemented, up to a global phase, by an ordered product
U = ∏ₖ exp (−i τₖ Hₖ) of piecewise constant evolutions (τₖ ≥ 0, Hₖ Hermitian, ħ = 1) whose
Hamiltonians have spectral half-width at most Ω / 2, i.e. ‖Hₖ − cₖ • 1‖ ≤ Ω / 2 for real
cₖ. Then the total time is at least Δφ / Ω, where Δφ is the gap between two eigenphases of
G on orthonormal eigenvectors.
Nelson and Barnes, How fast can a quantum gate be? Exact speed limits from geometry,
arXiv:2604.23031 (2026), eq. (3), state the general bound T ≥ Δφ⋆ / Ω_max. This file gives an
elementary proof via the shifted Mandelstam–Tamm bound (Duhamel estimate of
QSL.Qudit.fsAngle_exp_add_exp_le plus the triangle inequality of the Fubini–Study angle), and
only for gaps Δφ ≤ π. Nothing is claimed here about gaps larger than π; the full range is in
Formalizations.Physics.QuantumMechanics.SpeedLimit.SpectralArc (sphere angle, spectral arc).
For the two-qubit controlled-Z gate diag (1, 1, 1, −1) the eigenphases 0 and π give
T ≥ π / Ω, matching T⋆ (CZ) = π / Ω of Nelson–Barnes (Table I).
Main results #
QSL.Gate.fsAngle_le_time_halfWidth:fsAngle (U v) v ≤ (Ω / 2) · ∑ τₖfor unitvQSL.Gate.gate_time_ge_eigenphase_gap:|φⱼ − φₖ| ≤ Ω · ∑ τₖwhenU = ω • G,Ghas eigenvectorseⱼ ⊥ eₖwith eigenphasesφⱼ, φₖ, and|φⱼ − φₖ| ≤ πQSL.Gate.cz_time_ge:π ≤ Ω · ∑ τₖfor the controlled-Z gate
References #
- H. Nelson, E. Barnes, How fast can a quantum gate be? Exact speed limits from geometry, arXiv:2604.23031 (2026).
Mandelstam–Tamm bound for a product of evolutions. If U = ∏ₖ exp (−i τₖ Hₖ) with
τₖ ≥ 0, Hₖ Hermitian and ‖Hₖ − cₖ • 1‖ ≤ Ω / 2 for real cₖ, then every unit vector v
satisfies fsAngle (U v) v ≤ (Ω / 2) · ∑ τₖ.
Gate time from the eigenphase gap (gaps ≤ π only). Let U = ∏ₖ exp (−i τₖ Hₖ) with
τₖ ≥ 0, Hₖ Hermitian, ‖Hₖ − cₖ • 1‖ ≤ Ω / 2, and suppose U = ω • G for a complex scalar
ω (global phase). If G eⱼ = e^{i φⱼ} eⱼ and G eₖ = e^{i φₖ} eₖ for orthonormal eⱼ, eₖ
with |φⱼ − φₖ| ≤ π, then |φⱼ − φₖ| ≤ Ω · ∑ τₖ.
Cf. Nelson–Barnes, arXiv:2604.23031, eq. (3); this is an elementary proof for gaps ≤ π.
CZ needs time π / Ω. Any ordered product ∏ₖ exp (−i τₖ Hₖ) (τₖ ≥ 0, Hₖ Hermitian
on two qubits, ‖Hₖ − cₖ • 1‖ ≤ Ω / 2) equal to the controlled-Z gate up to a global phase has
π ≤ Ω · ∑ τₖ. The eigenphases of CZ on e₀₀ and e₁₁ are 0 and π. This matches
T⋆ (CZ) = π / Ω of Nelson–Barnes, arXiv:2604.23031, Table I.